Amazon Buys Lexcycle

April 28th, 2009 · 15 Comments
by Kassia Krozser

Did you feel the Earth shift a little bit yesterday? Maybe around 1:30 or so Pacific Standard Time (the only time zone that matters!)? Did you Twitter feed seem to be filled with jangly nerves? It turns out that Amazon bought Lexcycle today.

Lexcycle? Huh? Who? Erm?

Lexcycle is the mighty little company behind the bookish iPhone application darling, the Stanza Reader. Not only were they near first, they’ve been the best. With a strong focus on usability (or, if you will, making it easy for real people to accomplish the very simple goal of reading), support for ePub, and a growing list of public domain and new books, the literary digerati swooned.

(And before I type one letter further, I want to express sincere excitement for Neelan Choksi, Marc Prud’hommeaux, and Abe [of the missing last name]. Couldn’t happen to a nicer group of guys.)

I think a good number of us expected that Lexcycle would be sold (I was hoping Barnes & Noble would get it in gear because it fits nicely with their Fictionwise purchase and stated hardware goals). Being bought is a common trajectory for a technology company, and Lexcycle is a technology company. Perhaps that’s why Amazon stepped up first. They don’t think like a bookseller. Obviously, the usability and innovation from Lexcycle made this an attractive purchase; the question remains as to whether the Stanza Reader will remain standalone or its functionality integrated into the Kindle iPhone application.

Outside of the Stanza application, Lexcycle’s primary asset is its enthusiastic user base. It’s hard to be punk rock in the world of books, but the Stanza Reader came close. For us, Stanza represented independence — from Amazon, from Barnes & Noble, from iTunes. The Lexcycle gang were the outsiders who got it right and spoke to our independent souls.

Amazon just bought those customers.

Not to mention the foundation for other mobile devices. We have seen the future and it is this: people will not read on a single device, in a single format. We expect portability and we expect flexibility. Book-books are just one part of the mix; different kinds of reading, different kinds of books, will invite different kinds of digital experiences. This is why we, the community, were so excited about Lexcycle’s embrace of the EPUB standard. If you think of EPUB as HTML (over-simplifying a little bit), then you understand how getting the base right means maximum usability across platforms and devices.

While we can argue the merits of the Adobe engine, the fact that it gives us DRMd and DRM-free EPUB files is a huge plus. Right now, Amazon’s not on board with Adobe. The Kindle format, basically, is set up in direct opposition to pretty much every other ereading device (Sony, PlasticLogic, iRex’s iLiad, Stanza). If it’s true that men prefer the iPhone and Sony Reader while women prefer the Kindle (as rumored), then there goes the ability of spouses to share books. Uh?

I don’t think the Lexcycle purchase is the end of the world as we know it, but it should be a huge wake-up call for the publishing business. Amazon now owns the top two reading apps for the iPhone: Stanza and Kindle. The only possible contender in this space is the ScrollMotion product, and count me as one of many who aren’t thrilled about downloading separate applications for every book purchased. Unless iTunes suddenly changes its mind about adding ebooks to the mix — and until publishers make many, many things easier, including working with themselves, that isn’t likely — Amazon has a near-monopoly on iPhone book applications.

It also has the potential to shape other aspects of the marketplace. Recall, if you will, that one key Stanza partner is Fictionwise. Who happens to be owned by Barnes & Noble. Which happens to be an Amazon competitor. How long will this partnership remain in place?

(Of course, this could lead to a commentary on prices, but I’ll resist the urge. This time.)

If the Google Book Search settlement is approved, the vast majority of book discovery will be centered in the hands of two companies. The GBS settlement is, in my opinion, a result of the publishing industry missing the forest for the trees. At this point — and we’ll be talking more about this later this week — no other player can enter this space, even if the settlement fails to win approval. Who will pick up the pieces then?

Right now, it’s time for the publishing industry to step up to the plate. Stop worrying about fake issues like text-to-speech and start worrying about your customers. You may not be able to stop the settlement you negotiated and you cannot stop Amazon from acquiring better technology. But you can demand that your books be sold in the most consumer-friendly manner possible. Take the initiative to be a leader in the future of books — recall that your competition is changing rapidly — and you’ll be a leader in the future of reading.

There will be another Lexcycle, another innovative company that develops an iPhone app for reading. It will face the myriad challenges Lexcycle faced, including working with publishers to get books to readers (should be so easy, actually not). It will face the apparent commerce restrictions placed on apps by Apple. It might even succeed in the face of the obstacles that doom independent newcomers in the market.

As far as potential is concerned, IndieBound, at the moment, has my full support, but their success depends upon their ability to deliver digital books via the iPhone, to a dedicated device, downloads from a convenient location (be it local bookstore or IndieBound site), while ensuring that local bookstores get their fair share of of the sale. Many hurdles, none insurmountable as long as egos get checked at the door.

The Lexcycle sale is great news for the hard-working team that developed this incredible application, against so many odds. It’s not so great news for everybody else. Consumers are slowly being locked into a single vendor. Publishers are being backed into Amazon’s corner. Yet, yet, yet, I ask again: where are the publishing initiatives, the fresh thinking, to protect the free market?

File Under: Square Pegs

15 responses so far ↓

  • Debbie Stier // Apr 29, 2009 at 3:56 am

    I actually gasped outloud when I heard the news. It felt like one of those moments I’m going to remember 20 years from now. Still trying to fully process what it all means. A good friend who is very smart (David Naggar) is going to work as head of Digital Content for Amazon…..so I remain hopeful that everything is going to be good! Ride the wave….that’s my motto :)

  • Melissa // Apr 29, 2009 at 4:34 am

    Great insight. I also paused when I read it, as I was on the phone with a friend. Publishers, meaning print based NY types, are behind on ebooks by about 3-5 yrs, which we know is like eons when speaking of technology. Of course, there are several ebook companies who aren’t listed on many of these places(they still have not accepted to share the profits) and I see better sales with the one that do. Even in the economic downturn, my sales are holding steady or actually rising with these publishers.
    Amazon has been trying to corner the market on ebooks for awhile. From what I understand, they already tried to back publishers into some kind of exclusive agreement a few years ago with the kindle. Don’t get me wrong, I am very excited about the Kindle getting people to digital, but I like the free market. As an author, I want my book at as many places as possible, and I really don’t like the idea of this, mainly based on their prior behavoir(and being one of the many who had her book delisted and recognized the power).
    I am taking a wait and see kind of attitude on this, and hope the publishers do start stepping up to the plate.
    Oh, and I am a woman and I picked the Sony. I liked it better than the Kindle at present. But, I do notice more women going for the Kindle.

  • I’ll Repeat It: “Worry about Your Customers” - Ryan Markel // Apr 29, 2009 at 4:35 am

    [...] There’s more at the original article. [...]

  • Step Up to the Plate // Apr 29, 2009 at 7:47 am

    [...] Kassia: Right now, it’s time for the publishing industry to step up to the plate. Stop worrying about [...]

  • Kat // Apr 29, 2009 at 10:21 am

    The thing that’s so interesting is that it’s not only publishers that are behind on the ebook thing, it’s authors too. Just today there was a Shelf Awareness plug to a USA Today article that talks about how certain authors and authors’ estates refuse to go to ebook format becuase it might be “ephemeral.”

    This, the day after Amazon buys Lexcycle. When more and more people flock to Amazon, and, though they criticize, they BUY the Kindle. And then there are the thousands of other readers who actually like being able to download PDFs onto their readers.

    The point is, I don’t know whether publishers WILL get behind it if their own authors, VERY BIG AUTHORS (ahem, Rowling), refuse to have their lovingly-penned-and-forever-and-ever-lasting-in-the-beautiful-smelling-ink-and-parchment books put into ebook format, because, well, REAL PEOPLE don’t read books electronically anyway. And only the true literarians deserve to read their books in the format originally bestowed upon them, thankyouverymuch.

    This is exactly the kind of thing that is stunting ebook growth, as has been mentioned more than once on this blog.

    Of course it’s time for publishers to step up to the plate and be leaders in the future of reading. That should have been their job in the first place. But they won’t, and that’s the really sad part.

  • Kat // Apr 29, 2009 at 10:25 am

    Sorry about the broken link. The smell of books is talked about HERE (Hope that works)

  • Brett // Apr 29, 2009 at 11:00 am

    I used to say there would always be books…then again, I didn’t know a phone could work without a cord.

  • First Issue Blog » Blog Archive » Commentary Round-Up: The Amazon-Lexcycle Deal // Apr 29, 2009 at 12:25 pm

    [...] Krozser comments that the Lexcycle acquisition is not “the end of the world as we know it,” but neither is it great news for publishers and readers. Consumers are slowly being locked into a [...]

  • KatG // Apr 29, 2009 at 1:54 pm

    That’s too bad, but maybe it will work the other way — maybe this will encourage Amazon to dump the DRM from the Kindle, rather than convert Lexcycle.

    But I’m afraid that you’ll get no help from the publishers. They already are backed into a corner with Amazon. They could demand that Amazon drop the DRM aspect all they want and Amazon will just snicker. You’ll have to convince Amazon that it’s in their best interests to do it, and there will have to be options for the publishers to sell electronic rights or copies elsewhere that can compete with Amazon and force Amazon to change. The free market has to actually have a market — we don’t yet.

  • B.G.Sanford // Apr 29, 2009 at 3:50 pm

    Well technology marches on. I hope the industry will get on with it. I worry about the writers and traditional publishers.
    Well , before I leave this site, I suppose that I should mention my new book, “Beth:Love Along The Way….by B.G.Sanford,” and just released bu Eloquent Books. It’s the story of a woman who overcame all odds and two disasterous marriages to find true Love…………Along The Way. It’s an amazing story and if you’re so inclined, it can be ordered off the internet or have your local bookstore order it for you.
    Good reading………………
    B.G.Sanford
    http://www.eloquentbooks.com/BethLoveAlongTheWay.html

  • Stop Press for April 29th | booktwo.org // Apr 29, 2009 at 4:02 pm

    [...] Amazon Buys Lexcycle | Booksquare Was waiting to see some reactions before posting – as usual Booksquare has the best write-up. Hopefully, this will encourage competition, not stifle it. But Amazon *are* scary. [...]

  • Melissa B // Apr 29, 2009 at 9:00 pm

    Hi Kassia – fantastic post, as always!

  • The Publisher in the Value Chain 2009 Edition « Eoin Purcell’s Blog // May 4, 2009 at 12:59 pm

    [...] has launched the Kindle and just this past week bought Lexcycle makers of the Stanza App. They have previously launched their own iPhone app to try and capture [...]

  • Adobe ebook DRM crazymadness solution « Leekworld // Apr 3, 2011 at 5:34 am

    [...] Choksi), the best ebook reader ever – although less happy for their prospects since they sold out to Amazon.. Oh Kindle for iPhone. How sad you make me. Not quite as sad as iBooks. But pretty [...]

  • Sue T // Oct 19, 2011 at 8:07 am

    It looks like our worst fear is true: Stanza no longer works with iOS5! Is it the end for Stanza? Thousands of readers would like to know.